HNK Hajduk Split faces a pivotal decision on its goalkeeper position following Toni Silić's inconsistent performances and Ivo Ivišić's return from injury. The debate centers on whether to retain the young talent or revert to the experienced Ivišić, who has struggled to meet expectations since joining the club in 2025. Silić, 22, has been plagued by errors in recent matches, while Ivi, 31, has yet to fully recover from a prolonged injury layoff. Coach Garcia's recent comments have added fuel to the controversy, as he remains steadfast in his support for Silić despite the setbacks.
Ivišić's Arrival and Expectations
Ivišić joined Hajduk in July 2025 for €400,000, signing a contract until 2029. The experienced goalkeeper, a former Croatia international, had already won the Cypriot league and cup with Pafos before his move. Hajduk's sporting director Goran Vučević hailed him as one of Croatia's best goalkeepers, but Ivišić's early struggles have raised doubts. His early-season mistakes, including costly errors against Istria and Varaždin, have led to calls for Garcia to give Silić a chance.
Ivišić's Struggles and Silić's Rise
Despite initial optimism, Ivišić's performances have fallen short of expectations. His early-season errors, including a critical miss against Varaždin in September, sparked debates about his suitability as first-choice goalkeeper. Garcia, however, has remained loyal, allowing Ivišić to play 18 matches without conceding a goal until a serious injury in late November forced him out. Silić seized the opportunity, quickly proving his worth with 24 appearances in domestic competitions and a standout performance against Rijeka in February.
Silić's Impact and Future Prospects
Silić's rise has been meteoric, earning him a new contract until 2029 and a place in Croatia's senior squad. His 24 domestic appearances, including a crucial 0-0 draw against Rijeka, have solidified his status as the club's first-choice goalkeeper. Despite his recent struggles, including conceding 15 goals in 10 matches this season, Silić remains the club's most promising prospect. His potential for international recognition, highlighted by Zlatko Dalić's consideration for the World Cup, underscores his importance to Hajduk's future.
